Mama Shelby's Pizza

Discover Mama Shelby's Pizza in Rogersville, AL, offering delicious toppings, pickle pizza, cauliflower crust, garlic knots, and more. Perfect for families—featuring affordable prices, leftovers, and signature flavors like muffaletta and tiger. Call +1 256-800-6262!

View MenuMake a Reservation

Welcome to Mama Shelby's Pizza

Taste the Difference.

Mama Shelby's Pizza
Mama Shelby's Pizza
Mama Shelby's Pizza
Mama Shelby's Pizza

Located at 16428 US-72 in Rogersville, Mama Shelby's Pizza serves up a delightful twist on traditional dining. Known for its specialty pizzas and vibrant atmosphere, this eatery attracts both locals and visitors alike. It offers a unique array of toppings, including the popular pickle pizza, providing a distinct flavor experience that keeps patrons coming back. With a menu designed to satisfy every craving, diners enjoy not only the pizza but also numerous appetizing sides. Whether you're grabbing a quick bite or settling in for a family meal, Mama Shelby’s delivers tasty options that won't break the bank. Folks in the area appreciate the leftovers just as much as the fresh slices served hot from the oven.

Directions & Reservations

Plan Your Visit

Address

16428 US-72, Rogersville, AL 35652, United States

Phone

+1 256-800-6262

Social Media

About

The Culinary Story

Mama Shelby's Pizza
Mama Shelby's Pizza
Mama Shelby's Pizza
Mama Shelby's Pizza

At Mama Shelby's Pizza, the focus remains firmly on quality and community. This Rogersville gem blends traditional pizza-making techniques with a flair for innovation, elevating the dining experience. The restaurant's inviting atmosphere encourages friends and families to gather, fostering a strong sense of local connection. Each dish on the menu reflects a commitment to using fresh, locally-sourced ingredients, ensuring vibrant flavors in every bite. Patrons rave about the creativity found in dishes like the Pickle Pizza, which adds a fun twist to classic pizza recipes.

Foodies appreciate the range of toppings that invite experimentation and personalization. With options like the Butcher's Special or BBQ Chicken, there’s something for every palate, ensuring a popular spot for varied culinary adventures.

Mama Shelby's Napoli-inspired dishes offer a taste of Italy without ever leaving the South. Diners can indulge in pasta staples such as Spaghetti & Meatballs or Chicken Fettuccine Alfredo, with family sizes available for the hungrier crowds.

Moreover, the generous portions mean you’ll likely have plenty of leftovers to enjoy the next day. The restaurant's reputation for friendly service complements its stellar menu, making every visit enjoyable. Whether you're a regular or a first-time visitor, Mama Shelby's Pizza welcomes all with open arms and a warm smile.

Work Hours

Availability and Service Times

  • SundayClosed
  • Monday4-8 PM
  • Tuesday10:30 AM-8 PM
  • Wednesday3-8 PM
  • Thursday10:30 AM-8 PM
  • Friday10:30 AM-8 PM
  • Saturday3-8 PM

Mama Shelby's Pizza stands out with its impressive menu of 44 delicious items. Guests can choose from 11 specialty pizzas, including the famed Chicken Pickle and Tiger Supreme. Each pizza is crafted with fresh ingredients, ensuring that every bite bursts with flavor. For those seeking lighter options, the cauliflower crust caters to health-conscious diners without sacrificing taste.

Appetizers like cheesy bread and garlic knots set the stage for a flavorful dining experience, while sandwiches offer a hearty alternative. There are also delectable pasta dishes, perfect for larger groups or family-style dining.

Wings, both traditional and boneless, round out the menu, catering to sports fans and casual diners alike. Each dish aims to deliver something special, satisfying varied tastes and preferences all under one roof.

Mama Shelby's Pizza

Mama Shelby's Pizza boasts a charming exterior that beckons shoppers and travelers alike. Its colorful signage and welcoming entrance set the tone for a warm dining experience. Perfectly situated along US-72, the restaurant enjoys a vibrant atmosphere both inside and out. The dining space welcomes families with ample seating, and during pleasant weather, outdoor seating allows patrons to enjoy their pizzas al fresco. Engaging with local spirit, the restaurant often sets up community tables for larger gatherings, whether it’s for a spontaneous family reunion or a celebration spot for friends. The vibe complements the menu, making it a go-to place for a casual yet lively meal.

Guestbook & Reviews

Experience Through Their Eyes

On 10/11/25 We ordered the Butchers Special,some cheese sticks, and last but certainly not least the loaded garlic knots! ALL of the food was HOT and FRESH and some of the MOST DELICIOUS Ive EVER EATEN!!! HIGHLY RECOMMEND!! WILL BE ORDERING FROM HERE AGAIN!!

C
Calvin M.

I ordered their Italian sub. Let me tell you, it was a big sandwich! The toppings were fresh, the bread crisp. The garlic knots are a must have!! Also had the pizza with pepperoni, delicious!! Will always go there when in town! This is only half of the sub I received!

K
Kathryn R.

First time trying this place and it is my new go-to for pizza. They had me at sauerkraut (and if you haven't tried sauerkraut with pepperoni or bacon, you are missing out), but I was also really happy that the sauce wasn't sweet like some places. It was all really good. Not stingy with the toppings, perfectly proportioned ingredients, homemade dough, friendly staff - highly recommend! (The only reason I gave four stars for atmosphere is because it's really just a takeout place. But it looks clean and well-kept.)

A
Amy D.

Food was delicious. Cooked perfect and had leftovers. We fed 4 people. The cinnasticks were better than any we have ever had. This restaurant is definitely my new favorite pizza place.

D
David J.

Came down for a family vacation and ordered food at Mama Shelby's twice. The food was amazing. The kids loved the cheese pizza and their chicken pickle pizza is very good. I highly recommend the Shelby Jean sandwich (muffuletta). High quality stuff! Definitely recommend this pizza place.

A
Amber K.

We have eaten here many times and are never disappointed!! Just tried their new cheese ravioli and wow! needs to be a permanent addition to the menu immediately. Definitely recommend them.

M
Mackenzie J.